In the world of video games, a gripping narrative can create iconic, generation-defining experiences. But what happens when the story misses the mark? For some games, it doesn't matter. Not one bit.

These titles prove that a powerful, engaging, and social multiplayer loop can completely overshadow a weak campaign. Players will gladly skip every cutscene if it means just one more round with their friends. Here are five games where the story was an afterthought, but the multiplayer became the main event.

1. Anthem: A Narrative Letdown Saved by Flight

The Bad Story: Hyped as BioWare's next great sci-fi epic, Anthem's launch was plagued by a story critics and players called shallow, incomplete, and utterly forgettable. Despite a promising premise, the characters and plot failed to live up to the studio's legendary reputation.

The Great Multiplayer: So, why did people play? The moment-to-moment gameplay of piloting your Javelin exosuit was—and still is—spectacular. Soaring through the skies, diving into volcanic depths, and combining abilities with three other players in explosive co-op combat felt incredible. The core gameplay was a masterpiece buried under a messy launch, creating a dedicated community that rallied around the thrilling combat.

2. Destiny 2: A Universe of Lore, A Mess of a Narrative

The Bad Story: Destiny 2 has a common criticism: its delivered story is often convoluted and underwhelming, especially in its earlier iterations. Vital lore is often hidden away on external websites or in item descriptions, leaving the in-game narrative feeling disjointed for many players.

The Great Multiplayer: Despite this, Destiny 2 is a titan in the live-service space. The reason is its unparalleled multiplayer and endgame activities. The intense precision of PvP Crucible matches, the communication-heavy, puzzle-solving Raids, and the horde-mode-style Strikes created a addictive loop. The game isn't about the story you're told; it's about the stories you create with your fireteam.

3. Star Wars: The Old Republic (SWTOR): The MMO That Outgrew Its Story

The Bad Story: This is a nuanced case. At launch, SWTOR was praised for its excellent class-specific stories. However, as expansions rolled out, many fans felt the narrative quality became inconsistent, relying on repetitive tropes and moving away from the personal stories that made it great.

The Great Multiplayer: The true longevity of SWTOR lies in its identity as an MMO. The heart of the game for thousands of players isn't the solo story—it’s the social experience. Guild operations (raids), PvP warzones, and the simple act of exploring the galaxy with friends transformed it from a narrative RPG into a social hub set in the Star Wars universe.

4. Mass Effect: Andromeda: A New Crew That Couldn't Compare

The Bad Story: Following the original Mass Effect trilogy is a tall order. Andromeda infamously stumbled at launch with a criticized plot, bland new characters, and technical issues that became internet memes. For many fans, it failed to capture the magic of Commander Shepard's journey.

The Great Multiplayer: Surprisingly, Andromeda hid one of BioWare's best multiplayer modes. The co-op "horde mode" was fast-paced, required deep teamwork, and featured a fantastic progression system. The combat—with its smooth mobility and power combinations—was widely praised. For players, it became a way to enjoy the best part of the game's gameplay without the disappointing story.

5. The Gears of War Series: A Serviceable Story with Iconic Multiplayer

The Bad Story: To be clear, the Gears campaigns are fun, bombastic spectacles. However, the narrative across the series is often seen as a standard "macho men vs. monsters" trope. Some entries are stronger than others, but few players would cite the story as the primary reason they keep coming back.

The Great Multiplayer: The versus multiplayer and Horde mode are the undeniable soul of Gears of War. The weighty, cover-based combat created a uniquely tactical and brutal PvP experience. Meanwhile, Horde mode defined a genre, perfecting a co-op formula of teamwork, strategy, and defense that has kept players engaged for over a decade.

The Verdict: Gameplay is King

These games highlight a fundamental truth in game design: a compelling narrative enhances an experience, but rock-solid, social, and rewarding gameplay is what builds a lasting community. A weak story can be forgiven; a weak core game loop cannot.

These communities weren't built around remembering a plot twist—they were built around the shout of triumph after a down-to-the-wire Raid clear, the coordinated push in a PvP match, and the shared laughter of barely surviving a Horde wave.

What do you think? Did we miss a game that had a terrible story but amazing multiplayer? Let us know in the comments below!

• Share this post: