The nominees for the most prestigious award in gaming are in, and the 2025 lineup signals a dramatic power shift. This year's Game of the Year category is not just a list of contenders; it's a statement. With five of the six nominations coming from indie or indie-adjacent studios, the industry's center of gravity has officially moved.

The Nominees Are:

• Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

• Death Stranding 2: On the Beach

• Donkey Kong Bonanza

• Hades II

• Hollow Knight: Silksong

• Kingdom Come: Deliverance II

Let's break down what this surprising list tells us about the state of gaming.

The Indie Domination: Creativity Over Budget

The presence of Hades II, Hollow Knight: Silksong, and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 was expected, but their collective dominance of the category is historic. It underscores a fundamental change: creative risk-taking and artistic vision are now celebrated above sheer budgetary might.

This year's list feels less like a battle of marketing budgets and more like a curated gallery of the most innovative and passionately crafted experiences. It proves that players and critics alike are hungry for fresh ideas, even if they don't come from traditional AAA powerhouses.

 The Shocking Omissions: Where Was Ghost of Yotei?

The biggest talking point from this reveal isn't who made the list, but who didn't. The absence of critically acclaimed titles like Ghost of Yotei and Split Fiction has left many fans stunned.

This raises critical questions:

• Did these games, despite their quality, lack the defining cultural impact of the nominees?

• Were they overshadowed by titles with more groundbreaking or innovative core mechanics?

• Did the voting panel simply have a stronger preference for unique artistic styles and experimental gameplay?

Their omission confirms that a high Metacritic score and a strong fanbase are no longer a guaranteed ticket to the GOTY stage. The goalposts have moved.

The AAA Outlier: Why Kingdom Come: Deliverance II Belongs

Amid the indie wave, Kingdom Come: Deliverance II stands out as a powerful exception. Its nomination is profoundly significant.

The first game was a beloved cult classic praised for its uncompromising historical realism but often seen as niche. The sequel has shattered that ceiling, delivering a massive leap in production quality, narrative depth, and the complexity of its systems-driven world.

Its nomination is a victory for authenticity and deep simulation design, proving that hardcore, immersive experiences can compete for the industry's highest honour and potentially elevate the entire RPG sub genre.

The Front-Runner? Why Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 Could Win

While any nominee could take the crown, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 has emerged as a potential front-runner for three key reasons:

1. Innovative Gameplay: It masterfully blends turn-based strategy with real-time execution in a way that feels both fresh and deeply engaging.

2. Bold Art Direction: Its visual style is among the most distinct and memorable of the year, creating a powerful and cohesive identity.

3. Cultural Moment: The game didn't just release; it captured the community's imagination, sparking discussion and excitement across social media and beyond.

This potent combination of innovation, art, and buzz makes it a serious threat to even the most established franchises.

 How to Vote and Watch

Your voice matters! You can cast your vote for Game of the Year and all other categories at the official website: thegameawards.com

The winners will be announced live during The Game Awards ceremony on December 11, 2025.

Final Thoughts: An Unpredictable Race

Whether you're rooting for the indie revolution embodied by Hades II, the auteur vision of Death Stranding 2, or the hardcore realism of Kingdom Come: Deliverance II, one thing is clear: the 2025 Game of the Year race is the most unpredictable and exciting in years. The industry is changing, and the GOTY list is its loudest echo.

• Share this post: